I read some post about some league that basically started over by cutting down to 5 players. That would really suck, but it would be interesting. So here's my question to you...
If you had to cut down to 5, which 5 would you keep?
Warpigs go first:
1. Pujols
2. Beckham
3. Granderson
4. Fowler
5. Lind
Wow, that is a sucky group. Maybe it WOULD be a good idea to start over. Hehehe
SSWs
ReplyDeleteMauer
Wright
Markakis
Peavy
Jimenez
DVs
ReplyDeleteHolliday
Halladay
McCann
Kinsler
Beckett
(Although I would probably leave the last two 'blank' if I could get some draft picks from someone - LOL!
This exercise is a bit of an eye-opener. I'm fairly satisfied with the depth of my top 20, but I would be concerned about starting a franchise with only the top 5. I suppose they would have to be:
ReplyDeleteFelix Hernandez
Adam Wainwright
Mark Reynolds
Pablo Sandoval
J.A. Happ
The vote was close for number 5. V-Mart and K-Rod are not pleased. And if Roberts had not dropped to a 3, he may have been the pick. Speaking of picks, our first pick in 2010 may immediately alter the list. And no, I do not plan to trade that pick to the DV's.
we did that once in SOMNADA, and it was not fun to cut, but was one fun draft.
ReplyDeleteI only got two for sure
M. Cabrera and Ichiro
When a team excells the way the Inmates do it's tough to single out five...but here goes:
ReplyDeleteJ. Santana
R. Howard
A. Jones
C. Gonzales
J. Vazquez
Any wonder why we're so successful?
Wahoos:
ReplyDeleteYoukilis
Pedroia
Morneau
Rollins
Nolasco
The top 4 are pretty set (despite Rollins' bat). I'd probably have to think long and hard about cutting him and keeping either Baker or Hamels.
Fungoes would be hard pressed to pick just 5! Or was it Fungoes would be hard pressed to find 5 worthy of keeping!!
ReplyDeleteAnywho....here we go:
1 Clayton Kershaw
2 Rick Porcello
3 Matt Wieters
4 Grady Sizemore
5 David Price
#5 was almost a tossup between David Price, Denard Span and Ryan Zimmerman
Tweeners could have a a surefire #1 AND the 2010 and 2011 World Series ring if he'd listen to me about that ONE guy who would put him over the top.....
ReplyDeleteDrillers:
ReplyDeleteLincecum
Haren
Longoria
A.Cabrera
B.Posey (un-carded!)
I'd use Jeter as trade bait for draft picks from the Buckeyes.
dd
Verlander
ReplyDeleteBillingsley
Hanson
Texeira
Pedro Alvarez
BeeBoy